St. Clair transfers cargo to Indiana Harbor
05/22: 10:30 a.m. Update
The St. Clair may have sustained hull damage below the waterline Sunday, prompting it to return to Duluth to unload its cargo into another vessel so the extent of damage can be determined.
At 7:30 a.m. Tuesday, the St. Clair and Indiana Harbor remained docked side-by-side at the Duluth Port Terminal while St. Clair's unloading boom transferred coal into Indiana Harbor. Once that process is completed Tuesday morning, crew members and shipyard workers will try to determine what sort of damage may have occurred to the starboard side of St. Clair's No. 1 compartment. "They're unloading her and they think they have a problem in the hull,'' Ed Ruisi of Guthrie-Hubner, Inc., the ship's agent in Duluth, told the Duluth News Tribune on Monday evening. "We don't know what the damage is, if there is any. That's why they are unloading her. Nobody knows what they hit. They just don't know." Ruisi told the newspaper that whether the boat is damaged can't be determined until the cargo is removed. The Coast Guard is expected to investigate.
The St. Clair loaded coal at Midwest Energy Terminal in Superior and departed at 7:20 a.m. Sunday. It had passed Outer Island, about 90 miles out of port in Lake Superior when they suddenly turned back.
It returned to port that evening after the crew suspected it had been damaged. No word is available on what sort of damage may have occurred or how the crew determined that the vessel may have been damaged. St. Clair spent Monday tied up at the Duluth port terminal. Indiana Harbor arrived in port about 4:00 p.m. Monday and tied up alongside its fleetmate.Within about 30 minutes, St. Clair had begun transferring cargo to the bigger vessel. The two vessels are docked at the corner of the terminal near the entrance to St. Louis Bay, making the turn a tight fit for other vessels. The St. Clair was expected to move to Fraser Shipyard some time this afternoon.
Indiana Harbor and St. Clair docked side by side Tuesday morning at the Duluth Port Terminal. Al Miller
Original story
After being idled all day in Duluth, the MV St. Clair on Monday began the rare move of transferring its coal cargo into Indiana Harbor, which tied up alongside its fleet mate at the Duluth port terminal.
The St. Clair loaded at Midwest Energy Terminal sometime Sunday night, but by Monday morning it was tied up at the Duluth port terminal. Late in the day, the Indiana Harbor -- already due at Midwest Energy Terminal -- instead tied up alongside the St. Clair. By late afternoon, the St. Clair had begun transferring its cargo into the Indiana Harbor's hold, starting with the aft-most hatches.
To accomplish the transfer, Indiana Harbor had to tie up with its stern alongside the St. Clair's bow. This left several hundred feet of the Indiana Harbor's bow extending into the shipping channel where St. Louis Bay enters Duluth harbor. The saltie Neva Trader, departing from Cenex Harvest States grain elevator, elected to turn right and leave the Twin Ports through Superior Entry rather than try to round the Indiana Harbor's bow to make the turn toward the Duluth ship canal.
As of late Monday afternoon, no word was available on the reason for this rare vessel-to-vessel transfer -- possibly the first ever in the Twin Ports. Also, no word was available on whether the St. Clair was unloading part or all of its coal cargo. Even if it took the St. Clair's entire load, the Indiana Harbor would likely continue on to Midwest Energy Terminal to complete its load.
Pictures by Al Miller
A stern view showing Indiana Harbor tied up alongside St. Clair at the Duluth port terminal.
Closeup of the Indiana Harbor's stern.
Coal flows off the St. Clair's unloading boom into Indiana Harbor.
St. Clair discharging coal into Indiana Harbor.
Another view of St. Clair discharging coal.
Reported by: Al Miller and Eric Holst